Sadly, it looks as though this the last Independent cryptic – appropriately it is set by Eimi, the crossword editor.
Thanks to Eimi firstly for this final puzzle with it’s ‘farewell’ theme but secondly and more importantly for the dedication you have shown over the years as Crossword Editor, encouraging new setters and innovation in the ‘rules’ of crossword compiling.
We’re pretty sure that we have completed every single Indy and IoS cryptic since the paper was introduced in 1986 and we have blogged over 900 Indy puzzles on fifteensquared, starting with a Phi in February 2012. We moved to the Indy from the Guardian mainly because we found the Indy puzzles more creative and innovative, with a wider variety of setters – and we have Eimi to thank for much of that.
We really hope that Eimi and the Indy setters will find a home elsewhere – maybe in ‘the i paper’, but if not – it really is ‘So long and thanks for all the fun‘.
Thankfully, it is not ‘Goodbye’ from us as we still have blogging duties on 225 – a regular Inquisitor plus 2 Guardian Genius puzzles a year. It will take us longer than we hoped to reach 1,000 but we hope to get there sometime!

GOOD (righteous) BYE (extra – in cricket)
A homophone (‘read aloud’) of CU (chemical symbol for copper)
An anagram (‘translation’) of AI DISTORTS LATIN
Hidden (‘some’) in geisHA I FAncy
RoVER (‘one of the dogs’) with the ‘o’ (off) changed (‘switched’) to ‘I’ (on) – a reference to River Cartwright, of of the ‘joes’ in the Slough House books
MOOn (satellite) missing the last letter (‘waned’)
An anagram (‘unfortunately’) of TALKS FALL SHOrT without the ‘r’ (resistance)
An anagram (‘rearranged’) of CONCERT IF GAME
Alternate letters (‘regularly trimmed’) of dArWiN
A reversal (‘turned to the west’) of IN NUS (National Union of Students – ‘student body’)
AD (promotion) I (Independent) E (first or ‘initial’ letter of editor) U (middle or ‘essential’ letter of refused) – a sad but appropriate clue for today!
SO (thus) LONG (extensive) + a ‘reversal’ of DNA (genetic fingerprint) + THANKS (cheers) FOR (in respect of) ALL THE (complete) FISH (school) – a reference to the Douglas Adams book in the ‘Hitch-hikers Guide to the Galaxy’ ‘trilogy’ – coincidentally (or maybe not?) the theme for Thursday’s Indy puzzle by Kairos
C (first letter or ‘leader’ in coup) in GOTHA (German city) – although we had to check this as we had never come across this city before
nOAH (Hebrew patriarch) missing the first letter (‘losing head’) round BAD (awful) I (one)
An anagram (‘ordered’) of STRING BEAN I
A reversal (‘uprising’) of A ER (Queen Elizabeth – ‘former ruler’) TIRE (weary)
bELLy missing the first and last letters (‘trimmed’)
YAK (gossip) round SH and MA (‘two mums’ – one to be quiet and the other a mother)
UP (finished) SHOT (ruined)
A reversal (‘turned up’) of LEVIS (jeans) round (‘without’) N (first letter or ‘slightest bit’ of needework)
DAPHNE (nymph) after DO (party) with RHO (Greek character)
ANN (girl) + LA (‘the’ in French) in UR (ancient city)
THAT round (‘protecting’) IN (‘at the crease’ – in cricket)
IN DITCH with ‘ch’ moved from the back to the front (‘cycling’)
CHI (‘letter from Greece’) ANTI (opposing)
MASS (service) IF (provided)
PUT (state) SCH (school)
NILe (river – 12ac) missing the last letter (‘reduced’)
I’d like to echo everything Bertandjoyce say about this puzzle and eimi’s dedication to the cause, as well as adding my own enormous respect and gratitude to both B&J (or L&C) for all the guidance you’ve given to us solvers over so many years. Thank you all!
A big thanks to eimi and B&J. Very appropriate final offering, but when 1a and 5a slotted in I can’t say it was as enjoyable as it would have otherwise been…! Nothing to do with the quality of the crossword obviously, just made it all very real.
I’d hoped to try and help out with finding another home for all the Indy setters too, but today it feels like it might be a stretch too far. Hope there is some resurgence at some point though.
Can’t say I’ve managed as many Indy’s as B&J (I was only 6 when they started…), but thanks to eimi again for all the years. I can’t remember when how long it’s been since I missed completing an Indy. I still find myself looking at some other daily offerings when time allows, but none seemed to have managed the consistency that I’ve found here.
Thanks also to B&J for introducing me to this world, not to mention for humouring me in my attempts in setting too!
Hear Hear B&J.
I have never been sadder whilst completing a crossword and, what a tour de force Farewell it was.
As an extra bonus it contained a reference to Slow Horses, my favourite TV series by far.
I can only hope that we, as a group, will show the same resilience as River Cartwright and find a way back.
Huge thanks to Eimi and all of you.
Well, here we are at last. A nice puzzle by the boss with some appropriate sentiments intertwined. And probably appropriate that I needed a teensy bit of help to get over the line – I had the RHODO of RHODODAPHNE but there are quite a few nymphs and my knowledge of both them and of oleander is not good enough.
I suspect today’s comments will be full of thanks as well as goodbyes. Thanks to the Indy editor for building a super portfolio of setters and treating us to a myriad of well crafted and diverse puzzles over the years. And to the bloggers for their unstinting work, very much including those who might have ended up a gnat’s whisker short of the round thousand. I am sure you will get there. And finally to fellow commenters who, whilst they never seemed to be as many as they should be, brought cultivation, wit and appreciation to these pages.
Thanks all
PM
Thanks, B&J for a lovely blog and fitting tribute to eimi’s service as crossword editor for so many years. Thanks eimi for the farewell puzzle, made bittersweet by some lovely wordplay. I loved the substitution in 12a when the penny finally dropped and left me hopeful for an equivalent Slough House filled with an eclectic band of displaced setters! The surface of 15a sounds like a call to arms – what a brilliant spot, given the situation – and I hope that regular solvers, who perhaps have not yet picked up on the news, take note! Enjoyed 7d as a neatly clued NHO and loved 18d, and the poignant collection of farewells.
Thank you, eimi.
What a wonderful puzzle to end with.
A very sad day. I’ll miss the Indy puzzles and this section of the Fifteensquared blog.
Many thanks to all the setters, bloggers and contributors.
Valete.
Well, that puts the tin hat on that.
Thanks, all.
Bittersweet as Dan says. Thanks to eimi, all the setters and bloggers for all the entertainment, insight and innovation.
Thanks to all setters and bloggers. As subscribers to the Independent when it was paper and then not-paper, we have done the crossword every day for decades and will greatly miss it. And also very grateful to the bloggers on here who have enlightened us to tricky clues and enraging themes!
As a Canadian, I found the Indy cryptics to be accessible and solvable, despite my different cultural mindset. That is a tremendous achievement by the setters and editor! Thanks, eh?
And many thanks to the bloggers here! After finishing a puzzle (with a few cheats), I’d treat myself to fifteensquared for explanations I couldn’t see, and this made me get better and better…
Goodnight and good luck to all.
Chin chin. 🙂
Disappointed that this was finished but RIVER not parsed, had to come here for that, thanks B&J!
To echo PostMark@4 I could never understand why there so relatively few comments on 225 for the Indie crosswords yet the Guardian blog rapidly fills out with many having nothing particular to add, seeming just to like the sound of their own voice (in print). Perhaps that is partly an intimation of why the decision to end these crosswords was made, where there really not that many users? I would have been happy to see the astonishing overabundance of other puzzles on the Indie site pared right back to save the cryptic.
So long, farewell,
Auf Wiedersehen, goodbye.
B&J’s first and second paragraphs sum up my thoughts exactly
A very sad day indeed
Thanks very much to Eimi and B&J
A very fitting end to an illustrious institution. I am disappointed, as I have always trusted the Independent to act for what it appears to stand for… ah, well…
The strength of the field of the setters here, is a testament to the craft. Today’s was probably more approachable than some, but good to finish on a high… with a final nod to Douglas Adams, whose different way of seeing the world seems to be a good fit for crosswordland…
Thanks to eimi and Bertandjoyce
Very sad. I hope Eimi finds a role elsewhere in crosswordland – as others have said, his editorship of the puzzle has been exactly what it should be, and frankly puts others in the shade
Favourite TIN HAT. Thank you B&J, and most of all Eimi for a great innings. See you around, folks.
The Indy goes out in style. Nothing to add but thanks to Eimi and to all the brilliant setters.
I am so sad to have solved my final Indy crossword. The Independent was the first “serious” crossword I ever solved, and has been my go to for years.
Thank you to Eimi for this wonderful swan song, and for his hard work as editor. Thank you to the Indy’s army of wonderful setters who have consistently set fantastic crosswords, and especially those who have treated us so well over the past few weeks and ended the Indy’s puzzles on a high. I hope you all are able to continue setting for us in some way. And of course thank you to all the bloggers here who have helped me and many others immensely in getting into this fantastic hobby.
Thanks B&J and Eimi for a fine tribute to conclude matters, A sad short-sighted end.
I’d like to echo the thanks of all the above to Eimi and the setters of the Indy crossword. Like B&J I too have followed the Independent since its inception in 1986, and have been completing its cryptic crossword for most of that time. Alas, I fear the Indy may have lost its way in recent years and we finally cancelled our online subscription after they removed the letters page. We always relied on that to tell us what we should have read in previous editions.
My usual highbrow sources came to the rescue once again. Iron Man for Obadiah and Frasier for Daphne.
Very sad to see the end of the Indy cryptic. Since moving to Spain my appreciation of what a marvellous tool for expression the English language is has grown and grown. Unpicking the devious clues of such a fine group of puzzle setters has only helped to cement that feeling.
Final thanks to B&J too. I shall miss your blogging. Maybe I should check out the Guardian Genius.
Pete
A bittersweet solve with some great clues – SEE YOU, SUNNI and TIN HAT my favourites. There’s no other cryptic that has the same blend of rigour and irreverence that the Independent’s has – if this really is the end then there is much to be missed.
I can only echo the comments above, what a lovely solve to go out on, and how sad I am to see the Indy crossword go. Thanks so much to eimi and all the setters & bloggers.
Thanks and farewell to all. I hope something can be resurrected somewhere.
It was the Independent’s mixture of different style setters and different challenge levels, coupled with speedy, witty and authoratitve blogging here that lured me into Crypticland. I’ve only recently come to realise quite how special it has been. Sincere thanks to eimi and his team and to everyone who has contributed. You have changed my life.
A sad day. The Indy occupied its own special place in crosswordland and eimi gave opportunities to so many talented setters, which I thought proved to be a major strength of the puzzle.
Thanks to him for today’s highly entertaining, though poignant, puzzle and to Bertandjoyce for the appreciative blog. Good luck to all.
Thanks Mike for his stewardship of the puzzle and support for setters, and thanks to B&J for this blog and so many others. It’s very sad. Here’s hoping some kind of online successor publication emerges.
Well. that’s it. Didn’t quite finish. Couldn’t see RIVER, never heard of Slough House.
Probably started the Indy from the beginning, but I’ve often been unable to finish. (Not helped this week with my broadband going out for several days after a recent storm.) If I’m not getting it, I’ll give up.
A lovely puzzle (if some challenging fill) to wrap up the Indy. Echoing hopes that the setters will be able to latch on elsewhere, and that their new home is as welcoming to setters new to publication as the Indy has been.
A great thud of finality about this excellent puzzle from eimi. A very sad day.
I was an enthusiastic solver there almost from the very start in 1986 and it brought me back to crosswords after a break of some years. In those early days, Independent made a big thing of their puzzles, issuing a solving guide (which I still have). If memory serves, there were just eight setters at one point, four appearing weekly, and four fortnightly. Again from memory, these were Mass, Lucifer, Albipedius, Marcy (who set the first ever Indy puzzle), Portia, Aelred, Aquila, Quixote. (I learnt later that Albipedius and Lucifer were maybe one and the same.) All puzzles rigorously clued, fairly tough. though difficulty standard varied a bit (as is right), but always entertaining (only purpose of puzzles IMHO) and totally fair. Mike has been an excellent editor, there for more than half of the time, I think, but he did have a number of predecessors – again from memory Aquila (Bert Danher), Louise Levine, Brian Greer (Virgilius) and Michael Macdonald Cooper (Spurius).
As a solver, I was in touch with most of the editors at some point and was delighted to hear in 2006, 15sq was to start (founder: Neil Wellard) with blogs on the puzzles. I was involved in 15sq from the very start. I put an annual solving report of the puzzles up at the end of each year on the site. This was something I’d sent to the editors in earlier years.
As some will know, I was accepted, to my great delight, as a setter for the paper in 2010 (as Raich) by Mike, and I have had over 100 puzzles there, the most recent at the start of this year.
Thank you Bert and Joyce and all the contributors for their lovely comments. Is it goodbye? As far as we know, yes, but who knows what might happen when solvers realise that there are no more crosswords. Where there’s a will there’s a way. See you on the other side hopefully.
And I was thinking of moving Kairos to Friday for the Douglas Adams payoff but I didn’t think it right to deny Phi his last Phiday.
Oh dear, what a loss, kwaheri (goodbye) as we say here in Kenya 🇰🇪
Don’t usuallly do the Indy on a Saturday but thought I had best make an exception for this. Sad to see all the farewell answers. I guess there’s no going back now.
Fitting to see SO LONG AND THANKS FOR ALL THE FISH which is how I signed off my last job farewell.
Thanks B&J, Eimi and all the Indy setters over the years.
We’d like to say thank you to all the people who have left a comment today. The blog has had about twice as many hits as usual and there have been a lot of new names which is great.
We have written once again to the managing editor asking for a stay of execution and have suggested he looks at the blog to see how much the crossword means to us. It’s more than just a puzzle.
A day I have not been looking forward to at all. Genuinely sad as I filled in the last clue. Thanks to eimi for an appropriate finale.
In #31, forgot, sorry, to thank b&j for the excellent blog, latest of many, but far from the last, I’m sure.
I knew this puzzle would look about like this. I raced to access it before midnight UK time out of fear that it would be gone if I waited. I have only been a member of the Independent solving community for about two years now, but I will miss it. Thank you to eimi for the valedictory puzzle, and for all of the other puzzles too. I know that all the talented setters the Indy has fostered will find publishers willing to run their work, and I hope that another outlet will find space for new setters eager to cut their teeth the way the Independent has.
Oh, man. I’m relatively late to the party, having only discovered “British Crosswords” in the last ten years or so. But, thanks to the encouragement of Eileen and others, I’ve been hooked, reeled in, and thrown back to get even bigger. I do my “dailies” every day, which includes the Grauniad, the Indy, and 15 squared. I refuse to Google, or in any way seek help. If I lose, I lose. I am so proud to say that, today, I got the final Indy, and even was able to parse the whole thing. Thanks to all of you 15S posters for giving this Yank so many insights into British culture and cryptics. And now, I think I’ll go upstairs and invite my wife to view another episode of “Ludwig,” on BritBox.
A sad day, but fittingly marked with a super last hurrah from Eimi. Bravo to him and all those who made the Independent’s cryptic such a joy for so many years, and to the bloggers who helped me improve and revealed the myriad clever and funny devices that this puzzle in particular often showcased.
Such a shame. I remember being ridiculously excited when Eimi accepted my first puzzle for publication in The Independent in 2015 and I know from speaking to other compilers that they felt just the same. The quality of the Indy puzzles under Mike’s editorship has been extraordinarily high and the loss of the series will be felt acutely in crosswordland. I’d like to thank Mike personally and indeed in person over a cold one at an early opportunity. I’ve been living in Germany since 2005 and my link to the crossword world – thanks in large part to Eimi – has enabled to me meet numerous new friends, both in cyberspace and in real life, which wouldn’t otherwise have been possible.
Many thanks to Bert & Joyce too for their blogging of this fine puzzle and of course for so many more.
Best wishes to all, Rob/Knut
“All good things must come to an end”, so they say – but this end didn’t have to come so soon. Thanks, eimi, B&J and everyone.
Out of curiosity, I looked at the puzzles.independent website, and they are today repeating an old Atrica puzzle from October 2023.
A very sad day. Eimi’s curation of such a fine collection of setters over the years has been superb. For which so many thanks. And I feel for the setters, whose playful, intelligent snd head-scratching work has kept me happy for a long time. As a bit of an addict, I do the Guardian, FT and Independent puzzles every day. The Independent’s have been consistently entertaining and of high quality.
So thank you to Eimi for all the work and today’s elegant and poignant crossword. And, as ever, to B and J.
Just popping in to mention the puzzle I wrote in tribute to my fellow Independent setters, which was originally distributed at the Sloggers and Betters event last month. There’s a Fifteensquared post for it here (including a printable PDF) and it can also be solved interactively on MyCrossword here. Thanks again to Mike and all bloggers and setters that have made the Independent such a great puzzle series.
Dormouse@#44 today they’ve published a Knut puzzle – presumably also a repeat.
I can’t see that they have given any indication that they are repeating old puzzles and, if they are not paying the setters this seems to add insult to injury.
Hi @PJ
“today’s” puzzle is a reprint from November 1st 2023 and has the next serial number on from Atrica’s yesterday so they’ve simply turned the clock back 3 years.
There is zero chance of a repeat fee of course.
It’s all been said so I’ll just say thank you to eimi, all the setters and bloggers and yes, see you on the other side.
I wonder how many people that do the Independent crossword come to this site? Those that don’t will probably have no idea that anything has changed (other than an occasional feeling that a clue seems a little bit familiar).
Oh Friar Tuck, it’s over. Even with a sunburst finish from Mike, a sad sad sad day.
I set but 5 Independent puzzles (remove the B and the L from my surname, and think of drummers), but there were another 383 I penned as Tees, so I sure as hell had my fill, and I’m grateful to Kime (anag.) for every single one of them. P*ssed off about not making the 400 though 😀
I had The Financial Times under my belt — largely thanks to Albie Fiore and Colin Inman conspiring to get me in, rather than by any personal virtuosity — by the time I was accepted by MH at The Indy, but without the experience I gained working under his stewardship I doubt I’d have been good enough to get into the other esteemed organs for which I now peddle my wares.
Thanks again to Mike, whom I hope to see soon at some sort of a wake, and thanks to all the bloggers etc at 225. I wish my fellow compilers all the best, because you are the best.
How come I have an email from the Independent today 11 Nov 2026 apologising for the technical difficulties and promising that the cryptic will be back in a few days?
We took ( and paid) for the Indie from the start. Going paperless meant setting up the app in my name. Thank you to all involved for providing the daily challenge for myself and my co-solver. Challenging, entertaining and here and there frustrating but never dull. It will be very much missed – or will it? Any explanation for the content of Jane’s e-mail ? I need to know before I cancel my App. The Indie has become increasingly disappointing in the last few years. It is coming to look like an ageing parent trying to get down with the kids. I still miss the letters page where often the correspondents would mention their employment or life experience which supplied a context for their opinion. The Voices section is no substitute for the letters page and definitely not for high quality journalism. I will spare you the rest of my gripes re what the paper covers now. Please. Please can we have our cryptic crossword back pitched at the same standard we have all enjoyed.
Jane#52 and Kryptickate#53
First of all, it depends whether you are accessing puzzles from the app as a subscriber or from the webpage. It is our understanding that the Cryptic AND Concise crosswords will disappear at the end of November on the webpage. Since the end of October they have been reusing old puzzles. The cryptic puzzle disappeared on the app at the beginning of November although a concise puzzle is available. Whether this is a recycled one, we have no idea as we have only solved cryptic puzzles on the app.
We still are mourning the loss of some of the best daily puzzles.