Thanks to Goliath for a brilliant challenge.
Dependably enjoyable and witty. 19 down is a genius clue.
There may be more theme-related solutions in the grid, but I’m afraid I’m not familiar with the poem. If you are, let us know in the comments.
FAN (cool) + CLUB (bat)
SWAN (water bird) and SEA (water)
Double definition
Lupin is both a type of flower, and a bean (from 4 down’s solution)
AIRS (refreshes) + TRIKE (vehicle)
OPENS (starts) + [Googl]E (at last) + SAME (identical)
U[n]S[t]E[a]D[y] (occasionally)
PARADE (march) in which I’S (one’s) + LOST (gone astray)
READY* (*ground) to welcome LETTER (landlord) + (invite]D (finally)
V.I.P.S< (high and mighty people, <rejected)
(IN ITS PLACE)* (*shaped)
[B]LIGHTY EAR[thenware] (from)
[f]ORTNI[ght]< (<back, in a)
RAP (kind of music) + IDLY (with nonchalance)
(A BOY TEN)* (*playing)
Double definition
2. Family member’s ‘bon voyage’ at last, with a sigh of relief (6)
[bo]N [voyag]E (at last) with PHEW (a sigh of relief)
LANDS (secures) + CAPES (mantles)
SCRUM (rugby formation) + (MR (mister); I.E. (that is) welcomed)
[Sc]OTLA[nd]< (‘s,<rising)
The apostrophe is important in this case as it denotes possession and acts as the indicator of a ‘hidden inside’ clue.
SLIP (error) + SHOD (with footwear)
(ONE ACTED)* (*out)
E.G. (for one) appearing in NATIVITY (this theatrical production)
ILL (not well) kept by ARTERY (vessel)
(SE[a] TR[a]WLER)* (dismissed As, *out of order)
Double definition
(OT (part of the Bible, Old Testament) + L (left))< (wrapped, <up) in MIN[ute] (30 seconds, i.e. half a minute)
John Milton famously wrote ‘Paradise Lost’, an epic poem across 12 books concerning the biblical fall of man
R (Romeo, NATO alphabet) + TROPE< (literary cliche, <coming up)
BUSH* (*kind of) that’s about R (right) – &lit
STUD[ents] (50% of)
This puzzle set the needle soaring on my laugh-o-meter, starting with 1a/4, once I’d nixed the idea of ‘gust(o)’ somewhere in the answer. It was one of several clues earning double ticks today, along with SCRUMMIER, LANDSCAPES, OPEN SESAME and PLASTICINE (for evoking happy childhood memories).
I was, in fact, rather profligate with the swooshy ticks but then Goliath is always a reliable source of fun with tricksy wordplay (very sneaky ‘A’s in WRESTLER), fine surfaces (PARADISE) and good humour (the tastier rugby of 5).
Thanks to Goliath for a welcome ray of sunshine on a tropical, thundery day and to Oriel whose happy task it was to unpick the clues.
I couldn’t see anything else to add to the Milton clues but it has been many years since I read it.
Struggled for a while with 19d, but only because I’d misspelt PLASTICENE, without checking the acronym.
I learnt that a lupin is also a bean.
Nothing too taxing, and plenty of smiles.
I agree with Oriel and Diane@1.
My memory of the poem has faded too but I do remember the couplet from A Shropshire Lad praising beer:
Malt does more than Milton can
To justify God’s way to man
Thanks Goliath and Oriel
One small point on the blog. What clue is Oriel referring to when he says 19ac is a genius clue?
SM @4: Apologies, I meant 19 down. I have amended the text. Thank you
[SM @4, I like it!】
Good blog. I like Goliath’s style.
19D: One note on the parsing: I thought Goliath intended MIN[UTE] or “half [of a] minute” = 30 seconds, since a full minute = 60 seconds, of course.
1A: I had simply “admirers” as the definition.
Cineraria @7: quite right on both points. For 19D, my brain had processed the half minute, but then not explained it in the blog so I will amend that.
Great fun as always from Goliath. SLIPSHOD MILTON were my favourites. I got misled by the “this” in NEGATIVITY. Are the lupin bean and flower not essentially the same plant?
We did Book 1 of MILTON’s PARADISE LOST at school – nothing else in the puzzle rings any bells. Yes, the MIN part is definitely 30 seconds = half a minute.
Didn’t know LUPIN was a type of bean. Once again I entered VIPS/SPIV in the wrong direction (how do you tell?) until ADDING UP put the record straight.
Most enjoyable.
Was stuck on 21A as my final entry. Went for STIG (of the dump) as the reversal amused me and seemed somewhat appropriate 😁
In 19d, otl needs to be ‘up’ before being wrapped by min, so that wp needs a bit of forgiving …
Thanks Goliath and Oriel. A very enjoyable puzzle, but I share the misgivings expressed by Petert@9 and gladys@10 regarding 9ac and 21ac respectively.
Thanks Goliath for an amusing crossword with my favourites being OPEN SESAME, PARASISE LOST, BAYONET, ANECDOTE, and REPORT. I couldn’t parse MILTON because the ’30 seconds’ being MIN never occurred to me. I knew LUPIN because ‘lupini’ is an Italian snack I remember as a kid. Thanks Oriel for the blog.
This was fun. I only solved PARADISE LOST after I’d got MILTON and assumed another theme had sailed past unnoticed. I liked OPEN SESAME and AIR STRIKE.
Thanks Goliath and Oriel.
Great stuff only ruined by putting in STIG for SPIV.
Many great clues but MILTON was superb.
Thanks Oriel and Goliath
Nice crossword. Thanks, Goliath and Oriel
Staticman1@16: An interesting idea that the high and mighty could be ‘gits’. Perhaps they are in some people’s opinion.
Petert@9 and gladys@10 : Lupin plants {which may be annuals or short-lived perennials} produce firstly spikes of flowers, and then, on the stem where the flowers have died, pods of seeds which may be called beans {like the beans from other plants that we’re are accustomed to eating, which also consist of seeds within a pod}. In some cases {e.g. broad beans} we only eat the seeds, discarding the pods, in others {e.g. runner beans} we eat the whole thing, the fleshy pod with its small seeds inside.
Goliath delivers yet another great crossword. I endorse the generally positive comments above, although I did think some of the cryptic definitions were overly obscure. As GDU@2 wrote, there were plenty of smiles and I thought PLASTICINE, LIGHT YEAR, REPORT, ARTILLERY, RAPIDLY, and SLIPSHOD stood out. All parsed.
Thanks Goliath and thanks Oriel for a great blog
Good stuff from GOLIATH! I liked 16d with the “as” – “As” – misdirection. Took me ages to get 13d even when I had all the checkers!
Thanks @GOLIATH.