Independent 12,088 by Coot

This was an excellent puzzle from a very consistent setter.

The pick of the clues for me was 19A – possibly one of the best hidden definitions I’ve seen.

 picture of the completed grid

ACROSS
1 BACK SEAT DRIVER
Rugby players upset club, one making unwelcome suggestions (4,4,6)
Backs(=Rugby players) + eat(=upset) + driver(=club in golf)
9 BROWNIE
Toast? That is a delicious snack (7)
Brown(=toast as a verb) + i.e.(=that is)
10 BORSCHT
Child not quite right having eaten school soup (7)
Bo[y] + (r{igh}t around sch{ool})
11 SITCOM
Father Ted maybe to meet Catholic order (6)
Sit(=meet) + C{atholic} + OM(=order of merit). Sits is a synonym for meet in the sense of “The Council sits/meets tomorrow”.
12 MOLDOVA
Cast finished broadcast in European country (7)
Hom of “mould over”
15 ROUND
Shot that takes golfer hours (5)
DD referring to a round in a gun and the full 18 hole round in golf
17 MAELSTROM
Eddy West, dead in France, knocked over by Lexus on vacation (9)
Mae(=actress Mae West) + (mort<(=French word for dead) on L[exu]s)
19 DESCARTES
He thought he was mad, asserted leader of council (9)
(Asserted + c[ouncil])*. The def refers to Descartes’ famous phrase “I think therefore I am”.
21 BRASH
Husband against underwear that’s showy (5)
H{usband} next to bras(=underwear)
22 AGITATE
A soldier thanks those exhausted in campaign (7)
(A GI(=general infantryman)) + ta(=thanks) + t[hos]e
24 JOB LOT
Miscellaneous collection of biblical characters (3,3)
Job + Lot(=characters from the bible)
28 ON THE GO
July? I must avoid motorway – it’s busy (2,3,2)
[M]onth(=July as an example) + ego(=I in Latin)
29 ENDEMIC
Common disease to wipe out wild mice (7)
End + mice*
30 MAY CONTAIN NUTS
Can nuns act in time over contaminated food warning? (3,7,4)
May(=can, as used in sentences such as “Can/may I have a biscuit?”) + (nuns act in t{ime} o{ver})*
DOWN
2 AFOOT
Rear ducks to be restricted in the air (5)
OO(=ducks) in aft(=rear). The def is in the sense of “the game’s afoot”.
3 KEN DODD
Comedian‘s demise unusual: topped by butt of wisecrack (3,4)
(End(=demise) + odd(=unusual)) with [wisecrac]k on top
4 EVEN
What is 2+5 if you subtract 1 at the start? (4)
&lit. [S]even
5 TABOO
Unspeakable filling from fajita book (5)
Hidden in fajita book
6 REREDOS
Red rose transformed decoration in church (7)
(Red rose)*. A reredos is an ornamental backing to the altar.
7 VICE VERSA
Wrongdoing against Nebraskan periodically? On the contrary (4,5)
Vice(=wrongdoing) + v{ersus} + even letters of Nebraskan
8 ROTE
Thoughtless repetition,” lecturer’s marked on paper (4)
Hom of wrote
9 BESTRIDE
Mount champion horse? (8)
CD/DD. Champion horse = best ride.
13 SMUT
Corporation’s put up indecent material (4)
Tum’s<(=corporation’s)
14 EMPHATIC
Impeach President, ultimately turning decisive (8)
(Impeach [Presiden]t)*
16 UNSIGHTLY
You and me, every evening, entwined? That’s revolting! (9)
Us(=you and me) mixed with nightly
18 EASY
Lubed up Greek scored no problem (4)
[Gr]easy
20 ART DECO
Foreign actor accepting of French style (3,4)
Actor* around de(=of in French)
21 BROADEN
Extend course flanked by Scottish mountain (7)
Road(=course) in ben(=Scottish mountain)
23 TROUT
Fish in river caught by hawk (5)
R{iver} in tout(=hawk, in the sense of ticket touts etc)
25 LIMIT
Check statement of one chasing after lecturer (5)
I’m it(=statement of person chasing in a game of tag) after l{ecturer}
26 ZOOM
Unknown animal noise repelled fly (4)
Z(=unknown in X,Y,Z) +moo<(=animal noise)
27 YETI
Hairy creature besides Coot (4)
Yet(=besides)+I(=Coot, the compiler)

21 comments on “Independent 12,088 by Coot”

  1. KVa

    Good puzzle. Neat blog.

    Thanks Coot and NealH.

    Liked BACK SEAT DRIVER, DESCARTES (COTD), ON THE GO, MAY CONTAIN NUTS, EVEN,
    UNSIGHTLY and LIMIT.

    EVEN
    Did Coot also want us to think of 6, which is 7-1, is EVEN?


  2. Yes, KVa. I didn’t explicitly say it but that is the &lit bit of the clue for EVEN.

  3. KVa

    Thanks NealH

  4. Eileen

    An excellent puzzle, as NealH said.

    I particularly enjoyed BACK SEAT DRIVER, MAELSTROM (lovely word), AGITATE, MAY CONTAIN NUTS, EMPHATIC and DESCARTES, which I too had as pick of the bunch.

    I think I may have seen JOB LOT before but it still amused me, as did UNSIGHTLY.

    Thanks to Coot for an enjoyable workout and to NealH for a fine blog.

  5. Staticman1

    Great stuff from Coot but was slowed down by expecting a pangram at one point which I thought must be in UNSIGHTLY as I was expecting a U from US.

    Great stuff. As with others I enjoyed the long clues at the top and bottom.

    Thanks Coot and NealH

  6. E.N.Boll&

    An expert work of setting, something to enjoy in every clue.
    25(ac): “I’M IT” is very cunning.
    2(d), I suspect that ALOFT is the intended red herring; which is indeed, “in the air”. This phrase I think of as “something undecided”, whereas “there’s something in the wind”, means “there’s something afoot”. I’m only splitting ‘airs…it’s a solid clue.
    17(ac), MAELSTROM, the Mae West trick is a frequent play, but I still feel an indicator would be fairer to solvers who haven’t seen it umpteen times.
    Cool stuff from Coot, great blog NealH: cheers both

  7. PostMark

    As others have said, very smooth cluing from the ever-reliable Coot. DESCARTES certainly the pick of the day. Other big ticks included JOB LOT, ON THE GO and ROTE. The surface for YETI is amusing: those who have encountered the setter in person will know he chose his moniker due to a somewhat different follicular circumstance to that implied in the clue. Slight eyebrow raise when I encountered MAELSTROM which I would have considered somewhat more than an eddy but I see Chambers defines the latter as a whirlpool. Scale is the issue but I guess the lexicographers must have encountered some extremely small whirlpools.

    Thanks Coot and NealH

  8. Tim C

    Sheer brilliance for DESCARTES Coot. I tilt my hat to you. 🙂

  9. Hovis

    E.N.Boll& @6. My first thought for 2d was AROSE but it didn’t have enough ‘holes’, so to speak. Like other DESCARTES was COTD.

  10. ALP

    It’s all been said, really. DESCARTES is a cracker. LIMIT is smart, JOB LOT’s fun and the elegantly simple SITCOM took me longer than it should. Ta lots to Coot for yet another belter and NealH.

  11. E.N.Boll&

    Hovis@9 yes, me too, as they say…I initially suspected arse might well be involved! ” Rear duck restricted”, and we’d have cracked it open!
    But as you say, two holes were needed, whereas our “arse” only works with one hole.
    I agree DESCARTES was a good ‘un, but I vaguely recall similar clues before, along the lines…”The thinking man’s philosopher”.

  12. Dan

    Lovely puzzle. Really enjoyed all of this with particular likes for JOB LOT, MAY CONTAIN NUTS, BACK SEAT DRIVER, EASY, but could select more. As others have said, DESCARTES is wonderful. Thanks Coot and NealH

  13. TFO

    Thanks both. Plenty to enjoy, here, as a Monday requires. EASY was coincidentally no problem, however I don’t remember previously seeing ‘score’ rather than say ‘score off’ as a synonym for anything suggesting removal, noting it does equate to ‘scratch’ but not necessarily in that sense, or so I thought.

  14. Coot

    Many thanks to everyone who has solved and/or commented on this puzzle, and of course to NealH for an impeccable blog.

    I have enjoyed the chat about AFOOT. I’d realised from test solves that ALOFT might provide a distraction but the possibility of AROSE hadn’t occurred to me!

  15. TripleJumper

    Quite annoyed with myself for putting ALOFT instead of AFOOT, then coming here to see why LO is “ducks”.
    Thanks as ever to setter and blogger.

  16. Jayjay

    Thanks to Coot and NealH for excellent crossword and blog. I know DESCARTES is top clue, l agree, but JOB LOT; hee hee.

  17. Tony Santucci

    Thanks Coot for an excellent crossword. I had a long list of likes — BACK SEAT DRIVER, BORSCHT, DESCARTES, JOB LOT, ON THE GO, ENDEMIC, VICE VERSA, ROTE, and ART DECO. I initially entered ‘tums’ instead of SMUT for 13d (if you ignore the apostrophe in ‘corporation’s’ it works) but MAELSTROM cleared up my confusion. I revealed the nho KEN TODD as well as SITCOM, not aware of Father Ted. Thanks NealH for the blog.

  18. Petert

    Thanks to Coot for providing me with proof of my existence (i.e. making me think). Another AROSE here (ducks being another way of saying love). I have only myself to blame for googling the apocryphal comedians Kim Seed and Kid Smee.

  19. Hovis

    Petert. I wondered if there might be a Kim Seed but left the clue for a bit and when I next looked Ken Dodd immediately came to mind. So no wasted googling this time for me.

  20. AP

    DESCARTES made my day, one of many excellent clues. Thanks both!

  21. jane

    A late night solve for me but had to say how much I enjoyed this one. So many clever clues but can’t see beyond JOB LOT for favourite.

    Many thanks to Coot and to Neil for the review.

Comments are closed.