This week we have a puzzle from Kruger, the third most prolific setter of Inquisitors in the fifteensquared archive.
There was an extensive preamble for this puzzle – One of the unclued entries was responsible for another, which in turn eventually led to repeated destruction of the third. Before entry, three pairs of answers must be thematically modified (within each pair in one of two ways) to comply with a common phrase associated with this destruction. Each clue contains an extra word of
at least four letters. In clue order, the first or last letters of these words (equal numbers of each)
,describe how to complete the puzzle correctly. Numbers in brackets refer to the space available, and the grid contains only real words, phrases and proper nouns at all stages.
Last week’s theme was hinted at by the puzzle number, 1984. This week, the date of the puzzle’s publication (7th November) hints at the theme.
The first unclued entry I deduced was GUNPOWDER PLOT in column 1. At this point I had enough letters to guess ROBERT CATESBY would fill column 12. Frustrated by King James I and the continued persecution of English Catholics, CATESBY devised and funded the scheme to blow up the House of Lords during the State Opening of Parliament. The GUNPOWDER PLOT is remembered today by fireworks on Bonfire Night (5th November). Based on the first name of one of the other plotters, GUY Fawkes, THE GUY (unclued entry in row 7) is placed on top of the fire.
The phrase ‘a penny for the guy’ was often heard in years gone by as children raised money to pay for a GUY to go on the fire. I don’t think the phrase is so common now.
In clue order, the words omitted from the clues were:
| Omitted Word | Letter | Phrase | |
| Unusually | U | Use | |
| Strange | S | ||
| intricatE | E | ||
| scientisT | T | The | |
| Helping | H | ||
| troublesomE | E | ||
| Pantry’s | P | Phrase | |
| britisH | H | ||
| Ripe | R | ||
| American | A | ||
| Soya | S | ||
| desperatE | E | ||
| counciL | L | Literally | |
| alumnI | I | ||
| losT | T | ||
| theatrE | E | ||
| Ready | R | ||
| African | A | ||
| Latest | L | ||
| Love | L | ||
| unfortunatelY | Y | ||
| Oddly | O | On | |
| theN | N | ||
| frighteneD | D | Destroyed | |
| Ethiopian | E | ||
| reserveS | S | ||
| Tokyo | T | ||
| Royal | R | ||
| sohO | O | ||
| unhappY | Y | ||
| Everyone’s | E | ||
| colD | D | ||
| Irish | I | Item | |
| besT | T | ||
| rarE | E | ||
| Miserable | M | ||
| romanI | I | In | |
| Nearly | N | ||
| Greek | G | Grid | |
| fouR | R | ||
| Illegitamate | I | ||
| uniteD | D |
The amended clues are all shown in the detailed wordplay table further below.
The direction from the omitted words, which does indeed use an equal number of first and last letters (21 each), tells us to USE THE PHRASE LITERALLY ON DESTROYED ITEM IN GRID. i
There were six clues that led to answers that could not be entered in the grid. Taking them in pairs,
we had
CAMCORDERS (10a) and LINEALLY (31d), each containing shorter words that can mean GUY: CORD and LINE, which relate to GUY meaning a rope attached to a tent, for example. The phrase ‘a penny for the guy’ tells us to replace the words meaning GUY with either a D (old penny) or a P (new penny). The preamble told us that we had to use both D and P in each pair. While LINEALLY, could be amended to either DALLY or PALLY, CAMCORDERS could only change to CAMPERS. 31d therefore had to be DALLY.
PROTEASE (16a) and ORAGIOUS (27d) each contain shorter words that can mean GUY: TEASE and RAG. PROTEASE could have been amended to either PROP or PROD, but ORAGIOUScould only go to ODIOUS. To ensure that we used both P and D, PROTEASE had to become PROP.
The second pair ALCOVES and MANUALLY contained shorter words, each meaning a male person (GUY). ALCOVES could only become ALPS and MANUALLY could only become DUALLY (as confirmed by the crossing entries).
The final grid looked like this:
The clues were very fair, although there is one where I cannot pin down the wordplay completely. That is the one for ARIPPLE (24d), where the answer looks like an anagram. I can’t see an anagram indicator, so I may not be interpreting the wordplay correctly. For TOSSER (39d), I thought initially that we were dealing with an indirect anagram of SOT, but I couldn’t believe John Henderson would accept a clue of that nature, so I looked harder at the definition of ‘preposterously’ and found that it can mean ‘literally inverted ‘, giving us a reversal of SOT rather than an anagram.
We have had some difficult Inquisitors recently. I thought this was slightly easier to crack than previous ones.
The puzzle title ‘An alternative proposal’ refers to an idea (proposal) to replace GUY with a symbol for a penny.
Thanks to Kruger for an entertaining puzzle.
| No |
Clue Amended Clue Wordplay |
Omitted Word |
| Across | ||
| 1 |
Flocks of swans in unusually strong winds abandoning lake for entrance to marina … (5) Flocks of swans in strong winds abandoning lake for entrance to marina … (5) GAMES (a flock of swans [formerly of other animals] kept for pleasure) GALES (strong winds) with M (first letter of [entrance to] Marina replacing (for) L (lake) to form GAMES GAMES |
Unusually |
| 6 |
… to beat several other strange birds (6) … to beat several other birds (6) MURDER (MURDER is the collective noun [several] for crows [other birds]) MURDER (beat) double definition MURDER |
Strange |
| 10 |
Scotsman reviewed chapter on instructions for intricate video equipment (7) Scotsman reviewed chapter on instructions for video equipment (7) CAMCORDERS (portable video cameras and sound recorders combined into single items; video equipment) MAC (name for a Scotsman) reversed (reviewed) + C (chapter) + ORDERS (instructions) CAM< C ORDERS – entered as CAMPERS with P (penny) replacing (for) CORD (guy) |
intricatE |
| 11 |
Fellow scientist from organisation concerned with human genome (4) Fellow from organisation concerned with human genome (4) HUGO (abbreviation for the Human Genome Organisation) HUGO (name for a man [fellow]) double definition HUGO |
scientisT |
| 12 |
Wisdom possibly not helping an ordinary condition (4) Wisdom possibly not an ordinary condition (4) NORM (ordinary or most frequent position) NORMan (reference the comedian Norman Wisdom [1915 – 2010]) excluding (not) AN NORM |
Helping |
| 13 |
Teacher inconclusively resolved troublesome cases (6) Teacher inconclusively resolved cases (6) THECAE (sheaths or cases) Anagram of (resolved) TEACHEr excluding the final letter (inconclusively) R THECAE* |
troublesomE |
| 14 |
Steal most of pantry’s clean cut of meat (7) Steal most of clean cut of meat (7) PURLOIN (steal) PURe (clean) excluding the final letter E (most of) + LOIN (a cut of meat) PUR LOIN |
Pantry’s |
| 15 |
Bag of diamonds kept in Kabul’s British embassy (5) Bag of diamonds kept in Kabul’s embassy (5) BULSE (small bag for diamonds or gold dust) BULSE (hidden word in [kept in] kaBUL’S Embassy) BULSE |
britisH |
| 16 |
Enzyme transforming ripe pears to paste finally (4) Enzyme transforming pears to paste finally (4) PROTEASE (an enzyme that splits up proteins) Anagram of (transforming) PEARS TO + E (last letter of [finally] pastE) PROTEAS* E – entered as PROD with D (old penny) replacing (for) TEASE (rag; guy) |
Ripe |
| 18 |
Expressions of delight in joke American told (5) Expressions of delight in joke told (5) WHEES (expressions of delight) WHEES (sounds like [told] WHEEZE [slang term for a joke]) WHEES |
American |
| 20 |
Indian soya farmer a great success we hear (6) Indian farmer a great success we hear (6) RAIYAT (in the Indian subcontinent, a peasant or tenant farmer, an alternative form of ryot) RAIYAT (sounds like [we hear] RIOT [a great [usually boisterous] success) RAIYAT |
Soya |
| 21 |
Retracted desperate offer to buy fish (3) Retracted offer to buy fish (3) DIB (to fish by letting the bait bob up and down on the surface of the water) BID (offer to buy) reversed (retracted) DIB< |
desperatE |
| 23 |
Council abruptly axe the outdated right to hold court (3) Abruptly axe the outdated right to hold court (3) SAC (in Old English law, a right to hold court; outdated right to hold court) SACk (dismiss; fire; axe) excluding the final letter (abruptly) K SAC |
counciL |
| 25 |
Without a degree, downgraded alumni showed much anger? (6) Without a degree, downgraded showed much anger? (6) EMOTED (showed much emotion, such as anger) dEMOTED (downgraded) excluding (without) D (degree) EMOTED |
alumnI |
| 28 |
23 lost relics primarily are bones (5) 23 relics primarily are bones (5) SACRA (bones) SAC (entry at 23 across) + R (first letter of [primarily] Relics) + A (are, a unit of metric measurement)) SAC R A |
losT |
| 29 |
Retired theatre singer ignoring introductions to new Royal patronage (4) Retired singer ignoring introductions to new Royal patronage (4) EGIS (patronage) SInGEr reversed (retired) excluding N and R (initial letters of [introductions] to New and Royal) EGIS< |
theatrE |
| 32 |
Antique trader ready to give false information about price? On the contrary (5) Antique trader to give false information about price? On the contrary (5) PLIER (obsolete [antique] term for a trader) PR (price) containing (about) LIE (false information) P (LIE) R this is the opposite (on the contrary) of the construction set out in the clue |
Ready |
| 33 |
Current Rear Admiral fills wide opening in African waterway (7) Current Rear Admiral fills wide opening in waterway (7) IGARAPE (a canoe waterway in Brazil) I (electric current) + (RA [Rear Admiral] contained in [fills] GAPE [wide opening]) I GA (RA) PE |
African |
| 34 |
Accepted old origins of rating’s latest theory about life on the main vessel (6) Accepted old origins of rating’s theory about life on the main vessel (6) AORTAL (relating to [on] the main blood vessel that carries blood from the heart) A (accepted) + O (old) + RTAL (first letters of [origins of] each of Rating, Theory, About and Life) A O RTAL |
Latest |
| 36 |
Love birds beginning to like company inside old shady retreats (4) Birds beginning to like company inside old shady retreats (4) ALCOVES (shady retreats) (L [first letter of {beginning to} Like] + CO [company]) contained in (inside) AVES (birds, as a class of vertebrates) A (L CO) VES – entered as ALPS with P (old penny) replacing (for) TEASE (rag; guy) |
Love |
| 37 |
Burden concerning you and unfortunately me (4) Burden concerning you and me (4) ONUS (burden) ON (concerning) + US (you and me) ON US |
unfortunatelY |
| 38 |
Closely examine dead brood – oddly black on each side (7) Closely examine dead brood – black on each side (7) EYEBALL (closely examine) EYE (obsolete [dead] word for a brood of pheasants) + B (black when referring to pencil lead) + ALL (on each side) EYE B ALL |
Oddly |
| 39 |
Drunk, preposterously devours second and third portions of fish stew then throws up (6) Drunk, preposterously devours second and third portions of fish stew throws up (6) TOSSES (throws up, e.g. tosses a coin)) SOT (drunk) reversed (preposterously; literally inverted) containing (S [second] + SE (3rd letter of [third portions] of each of fiSh and stEw) TO (S SE) S* |
theN |
| 40 |
Frightened terrier ultimately wary of the weather (5) Terrier ultimately wary of the weather (5) SKYEY (of the weather) SKYE (reference a SKYE terrier [a small long-haired Scottish terrier]) + Y (last letter of [ultimately] warY) SKYE Y |
frighteneD |
| Down | ||
| 2 |
Ethiopian rodent to lie down in wadi on a regular basis (7) Rodent to lie down in wadi on a regular basis (7) ACOUCHI (a kind of small S American rodent) COUCH (to lie down for the purpose of sleep, concealment etc) contained in (in) AI (letters 2 and 4 [on a regular basis] of wAdI) A (COUCH) I |
Ethiopian |
| 3 |
Join Republican army reserves in revolution (5) Join Republican army in revolution (5) MARRY (unite, join) Anagram of (in revolution) R (Republican) and ARMY MARRY* |
reserveS |
| 4 |
Track’s in a sorry state after end of Tokyo Olympics (5) Track’s in a sorry state after end of Olympics (5) SPOOR (a track or trail) S (last letter of [end of] olympicS) + POOR (in a sorry state) S POOR |
Tokyo |
| 5 |
Polite Royal Engineers initially rebuilt part of plant (7) Polite Engineers initially rebuilt part of plant (7) PETIOLE (a leaf-stalk, part of a plant) Anagram of (rebuilt) POLITE and E (first letter of [initially] Engineers) PETIOLE* |
Royal |
| 7 |
Routinely take profit from Soho property (3) Routinely take profit from property (3) USE (routine take, e.g. a drug) USE (profit derived from property) double definition USE |
sohO |
| 8 |
Perhaps bishop leads unhappy university friend by the hand (6) Perhaps bishop leads university friend by the hand (6) MANUALLY (by the hand) MAN (a bishop is a man on a chess board) + U (university) + ALLY (friend) MAN U ALLY – entered as DUALLY with D (old penny) replacing (for) MAN (male person; guy) |
unhappY |
| 9 |
English visitor about to dispose of first of everyone’s unnecessary waste (6) English visitor about to dispose of first of unnecessary waste (6) EGESTA (waste materials) (E [English] + GuEST [visitor] + A [about]) excluding (to dispose of) U (initial letter of [first of] Unnecessary) E GEST A |
Everyone’s |
| 15 |
Boyfriends in Bahamas drinking cold Evian water (5) Boyfriends in Bahamas drinking Evian water (5) BEAUS (boyfriends) BS (international Vehicle Registration for The Bahamas) containing (drinking) EAU (French [Evian is a town in France] for water) B (EAU) S |
colD |
| 16 |
Cherished, truly exhausted Irish officer may be so (5) Cherished, truly exhausted officer may be so (5) PETTY (reference a naval PETTY Officer) PET (cherished) + TY (letters remaining in TrulY when the central letters rul are removed [exhausted]) PET TY |
Irish |
| 17 |
Upset adult hostel stopping best man’s greetings (5) Upset adult hostel stopping man’s greetings (5) HIYAS (greetings) (A [adult] + Y [a YMCA or YWCA hostel]) reversed (upset) contained in (stopping) HIS (man’s) HI (Y A)< S |
besT |
| 19 |
Female with rare Arabian tonsure (5) Female with Arabian tonsure (5) SHEAR (to shave; to tonsure) SHE (female) + AR (Arabian) SHE AR |
rarE |
| 22 |
Locally fun German entertains miserable Liberal – he laughs! (7) Locally fun German entertains Liberal – he laughs! (7) GIGGLER (a person who laughs; he laughs) GIG (dialect [locally] word for ‘fun’) + (GER [GERman] containing [entertains] L [Liberal]) GIG G (L) ER |
Miserable |
| 24 |
Topless Romani pipe player, evidently on vacation, goes with a little wave (7) Topless pipe player, evidently on vacation, goes with a little wave (7) ARIPPLE (with a little wave) Anagram of (?) pIPE excluding the first letter P (topless) and PLAyeR excluding (goes) EY (letters remaining in EvidentlY when the central letters videntl are removed [on vacation) ARIPPLE* |
romanI |
| 26 |
Italian city of Cremona nearly limited uprising (6) Italian city of Cremona limited uprising (6) MILANO (Italian city [Italian spelling]) MILANO (reversed [uprising] hidden word in [of] cremONA LIMited) MILANO< |
Nearly |
| 27 |
Rarely stormy Greek husband departed hours ago – I relaxed (6) Rarely stormy husband departed hours ago – I relaxed (6) ORAGIOUS (rare word for stormy) Anagram of (relaxed) hOURS AGO I excluding (departed) H (husband) ORAGIOUS* – – entered as ODIOUS with D (old penny) replacing (for) RAG (tease; guy) |
Greek |
| 30 |
Feet of four young sheep different at the front (5) Feet of young sheep different at the front (5) IAMBS (feet of two syllables) lAMBS (young sheep) with L replaced by I at the beginning of the word (different at the front) IAMBS |
fouR |
| 31 |
As legitimate descent, Lambert and I almost left to succeed illegitimate imposter at last (5) As legitimate descent, Lambert and I almost left to succeed imposter at last (5) LINEALLY (as legitimate descent) L (lambert, unit of brightness) + I + NEArLY (almost with L [left] replacing [to succeed] R [final letter of [at last] imposteR) to form NEALLY L I NEALLY – entered as DALLY with D (old penny) replacing (for) LINE (rope; guy) |
Illegitimate |
| 35 |
United supporter leaves broadcast (3) Supporter leaves broadcast (3) TEE (supporter for a golf ball) TEE (sounds like [broadcast] TEA [leaves]) TEE |
uniteD |
