Guardian 30,123: Brummie

Thanks to Brummie for today’s puzzle. Perhaps a touch above the usual Monday difficulty level, but nicely clued as ever.

 
Across
1 CRISIS Plight of conflicted Republican heads leading double lives (6)
First letters of Conflicted Republican + IS (lives) twice
5 SOB STORY Pitiful account of boss turned politician (3,5)
BOSS* + TORY (politician)
9 FREELOAD Sponge’s loose weight (8)
FREE (loose) + LOAD (weight)
10 SLEUTH Dick playing lute to break silence (6)
LUTE* in SH (silence!)
11 ANTIMACASSAR Applying mascara isn’t a protection against greasy hair (12)
(MASCARA ISN’T A)*. Antimacassars were (are?) put on chairs to protect them from the macassar oil that men put in their hair
13 SCUD Rocket salad starter with re-processed food (4)
S[alad] + CUD (“reprocessed” food in ruminants)
14 NUMERACY Never underestimate Middle Eastern leaders with lively ability to put two and two together (8)
First letters of Never Underestimate Middle Eastern + RACY (lively)
17 VALENCIA City’s very bitter new agents? (8)
V[ery] + ALE (beer, bitter) + N[ew] + CIA (agents)
18 GREW Team leader changed, became mature (4)
CREW (team) with a different first letter
20 BIRTHDAY SUIT A British duty to spread nudity (8,4)
(A BRITISH DUTY)*
23 INFIRM Part of company that’s failing (6)
If you’re part of a company you’re IN [a] FIRM
24 OUTHOUSE Privy you once dumped in river? (8)
THOU (old form of “you”) in OUSE (river)
25 FLATPACK Apartment charge for potential item of furniture? (8)
FLAT (apartment) + PACK (to load0
26 DO-SI-DO Dance figure is switched between two parties (2-2-2)
Reverse of IS between DO and DO (parties)
Down
2 RARE Excellent red for the diner? (4)
Double definition: rare/red as in steak etc
3 SKEDADDLE Somewhat over-tasked, add lead to make tracks (9)
Hidden in over-taSKED ADD LEad
4 SNOOTY Superior toys on high (6)
(TOYS ON)*
5 SEDIMENTARY ROCK White Cliffs of Dover composition – morris dance yet to be arranged by Kay (11,4)
(MORRIS DANCE YET)* + K
6 BASE CAMP Wretched, mannered start of assault on Everest? (4,4)
BASE (wretched) + CAMP (mannered)
7 TRESS Not opening, force lock (5)
STRESS (force) without its first letter
8 RAT-CATCHER The Pied Piper of abstract art – baseball player? (3-7)
ART* + CATCHER
12 OCCASIONAL Intermittent sort of casino in Ohio state (10)
CASINO* in O (Ohio – this one-letter abbreviation is in Chambers) +CAL[ifornia]
15 RIGHTEOUS Just a blend of proper English and ordinary American (9)
RIGHT (proper) + E[nglish] + O[rdinary] + US
16 ACADEMIA Uplifted, set sights on getting one around a scholarly environment (8)
Reverse of AIMED (set sights on) + A (one) + CA (circa, around)
19 GUTTED Was a fish factory worker disappointed? (6)
Double definition
21 TAINT Soil: it isn’t common (5)
TAIN’T is a slang form of “it isn’t”
22 USED In-house detective was a druggie (4)
Hidden in in-hoUSE Detective. The use of the derogatory term “druggie” has caused some raised eyebrows in the Guardian comments

45 comments on “Guardian 30,123: Brummie”

  1. Drofle's avatar
    Drofle

    A very nice puzzle! Brummie on top form, I reckon. Loved OUTHOUSE, CRISIS, SOB STORY and SEDIMENTARY ROCK in particular. Many thanks to B & A.

  2. DaveEllison's avatar
    DaveEllison

    Reading your blog, made me realise not a duff surface anywhere; in fact some excellent ones such as 20ac.

    Thanks, Andrew and Brummie

  3. bodycheetah's avatar
    bodycheetah

    Lovely start to the week. A real lightness of touch from Brummie today. Top ticks for ANTIMACASSAR, SOB STORY and VALENCIA

    I think the angst over druggie in the other place tells you everything you need to know about something or other

    Cheers A&B

  4. William's avatar
    William

    Bunged in RIGHTEOUS with a slight shrug… didn’t know Ohio could be reduced to a single O. Is that the case with all the US states or just some?

  5. AlanC's avatar
    AlanC

    Excellent start to the week with not a dud in sight. I liked SLEUTH, NUMERACY, BIRTHDAY SUIT and SEDIMENTARY ROCK. We still use ANTIMACASSARS.

    Ta Brummie & Andrew.

  6. Petert's avatar
    Petert

    What AlanC@5 said.

  7. Protase's avatar
    Protase

    Excellent puzzle with good constructions and surfaces. I was encouraged by the beautiful CRISIS and the rest lived up to expectation.

    Slight change of wording to ‘Dance figure is switchING….’ would make DO-SI-DO an &lit, do you not think?

    Many thanks to Brummie and Andrew

  8. Eileen's avatar
    Eileen

    Super start to the week! The long anagrams are all brilliant – very satisfying to work out – with excellent surfaces all round.

    Same favourites as AlanC @5, with the addition of SOB STORY, RAT-CATCHER and ACADEMIA.

    Many thanks to Brummie and Andrew.

  9. michelle's avatar
    michelle

    5d was an impressive anagram!

    New for me: DO-SI-DO (= US alteration aka mangling of dos-à-dos); O = Ohio (I usually see OH).

  10. SimoninBxl's avatar
    SimoninBxl

    Some brilliant anagrams – 20A and 5D stand out. Otherwise what AlanC@5 said – except I haven’t seen an antimacassar since my Grandmother died in the 70s. Thanks to B & A.

  11. Menander's avatar
    Menander

    I was also thrown by O for Ohio – which seems to have been the abbreviation accepted by the US Postal Service from 1831-1874. O well.

  12. Geoff Down Under's avatar
    Geoff Down Under

    Very nice. I don’t understand pack/charge in 25a. I struggle to equate rare with excellent, despite someone assuring me a long time ago that the Chambers bible says it’s OK. Cholera is rare. Today’s weather is excellent.

    I too was surprised by O for Ohio.

  13. Hadrian's avatar
    Hadrian

    Agree with all above, Brummie is King of surfaces, a great read as well as a great puzzle. SimoninBxL@10, try travelling Avanti west coast for present day ANTIMACASSARs. We’ll have to see if they survive nationalisation.

  14. gladys's avatar
    gladys

    William @4: I have seen Oregon similarly reduced to its initial O in “Salem, O”, but I don’t know if it’s legit for every state.

    Very enjoyable, thanks Brummie. I liked OUTHOUSE and SOB STORY and BIRTHDAY SUIT, and was forced to address the question of how to spell DO-SI-DO, which I have often heard but never seen written down. Yes, ANTIMACASSARS on chairs long survived any actual need for them – our chairs sported them well into the1980s.

    (Geoff Down Under@12 – how about O rare Ben Jonson?)

  15. Wellbeck's avatar
    Wellbeck

    I agree with DaveE @2 about the surfaces – though I reckon the one for OUTHOUSE is as good as BIRTHDAY SUIT.
    I also agree with all those who were thrown by Ohio being just the letter O. Random Initialitis strikes again. However, that one harrumph was outnumbered by the happy ticks and grins…
    Thanks Brummie and Andrew

  16. poc's avatar
    poc

    Very smooth and enjoyable, though I couldn’t quite parse OCCASIONAL.

  17. Balfour's avatar
    Balfour

    GDU @12 RARE = excellent is current certainly in the Glaswegian patois I grew up with ‘ ‘That’s RERR!’ is an expression commonly heard. On a more – ahem – elevated note, in Antony and Cleopatra, Agrippa interrupts Enobarbus’s famous ‘The barge she sat on, like a burnished throne …’ speech, exclaiming ‘O rare for Antony’. It is not to be supposed that he is giving the palace chef instructions for how to cook Antony’s steak later.

  18. grantinfreo's avatar
    grantinfreo

    Agree, GDU @12, about pack and charge — you can charge your glass but not your suitcase — but I’m less fussed about rare and excellent. Great puzzle, ta Brum and Andrew.

  19. Robi's avatar
    Robi

    Very good start to the week. Of course, O = Ohio is in Chambers. I liked the boss’s SOB STORY, the good anagrams for BIRTHDAY SUIT and SEDIMENTARY ROCK, the OUTHOUSE privy in the river, the well-hidden SKEDADDLE, and the OCCASIONAL casino.

    Thanks Brummie and Andrew.

  20. Martin's avatar
    Martin

    It’s all been said, I think, although I had no complaints. I quite liked RAT CATCHER, among others. SEDIMENTARY ROCK was good, I was duly misdirected for a start.

  21. Geoff Down Under's avatar
    Geoff Down Under

    Thank you for the enlightenment, Balfour@17. I shall draw on this next time I’m in Glasgow. 🙂

  22. wynsum's avatar
    wynsum

    Lovely start to the week – I liked everything but especially the dumped privy, the high toys and the spread nudity!
    Thanks Brummie & Andrew

  23. Daniel's avatar
    Daniel

    What is a FLATPACK?

  24. Robi's avatar
    Robi

    Daniel @23; from Chambers: flatˈpack noun

    An item of furniture or equipment sold in a flat pack for the purchaser to assemble

  25. Grizzlebeard's avatar
    Grizzlebeard

    Daniel@23 A flatpack is a kind of large-ish jigsaw puzzle enjoyed by DIY enthusiasts. Like a crossword, the flatpack comes with a set of clues designed to baffle and misdirect.

  26. Amma's avatar
    Amma

    Daniel@23 You’ve obviously never shopped in Ikea!

  27. Naive_springwater's avatar
    Naive_springwater

    Gif@18 – I had parsed ‘charge’ and ‘pack’ in the sense of “charging” or “packing” a firearm, but I agree wasn’t the most immediate sense of “charge”. Also hope the AFL result on Saturday wasn’t too gutting if you’re a Fremantle supporter – superb game!

    An enjoyable puzzle and thanks to Brummie and Andrew

  28. Chrisp's avatar
    Chrisp

    Is the definition for outhouse possibly also privy you once dumped in?

  29. ronald's avatar
    ronald

    Not very often that a hidden word stays that way almost to the very end, but that was the case with SKEDADDLE today. Which meant I could finally insert FREELOAD. An entertaining puzzle this morning, I thought. Many thanks Brummie and Andrew…

  30. Staticman1's avatar
    Staticman1

    I was going to say slightly harder than a usual Monday but looking back afterwards there were only a few clues for which I didn’t think I should have got a lot quicker. ANTIMACASSAR was new to me but seemed the most likely of the unlikely possible order or letters.

    Liked a lot of this. SEDIMENTARY ROCK, BIRTHDAY SUIT and BASE CAMP come straight to mind.

    Thanks Brummie and Andrew

  31. ysc's avatar
    ysc

    Lovely puzzle with many great surfaces and ingenious anagrams. Since my sister once lived in Hamelin, I particularly enjoyed 8d. Thanks Brummie and Andrew!

  32. Valentine's avatar
    Valentine

    What a fine puzzle! I really enjoyed the excellent anagrams and the clever clues.

    Let me set the record straight on US state abbreviations (and Canadian province ones too). In 1969 the post office declared that every state, no exceptions, had a two-letter abbreviation, with both letters capitalized. William@4, California is CA, not Cal. My state, Connecticut is CT, not CN as somebody once put it, which stands for cyanide.

    Before 1969 state abbreviations were of variable size. I think I recall both Cal and Calif for California. Tennessee was Tenn, I think, but Kentucky was Ken. Four-letter abbreviations were common, but what do you do when the whole state name is only four letters? Apparently you shorten it to just O because using the whole four letters wouldn’t be an abbreviation, would it? Though I don’t think Utah, our other four-letter state, suffered the same fate.

    It may have been my grandmother who told me what an antimacassar was, and I’m sure I haven’t seen one in ages. Do men still use hair oil in your neck of the woods, AlanC?

    I think ‘taint for “it isn’t” is dialect, not slang.

    Michelle@8 Do-si-do is orally transmitted French, as our square dance tradition is descended from French quadrilles (without lobsters). Other square dance terms from French are promenade, sashay (chasser) and allemand left (a la main gauche).

    Thanks, Brummie and Andrew.

  33. Jacob's avatar
    Jacob

    Having lived in the US for over 30 years, I have absolutely never, ever seen any US state reduced to a single letter. There are simply too many ambiguities. Without exception they are abbreviated to the official two letter codes accepted by the USPS. Once again “it’s in Chambers” fails to impress me: necessary, perhaps, but not sufficient.

    It’s a shame to have a — let’s say it out loud — error like that mar an otherwise excellent Monday puzzle, especially as there are so many other ways to clue O.

  34. Valentine's avatar
    Valentine

    Jacob, the letter O once was once the official abbreviation for Ohio, though it hasn’t been since 1969 — longer ago than your 30 years. Read the comments before you post.

  35. Jacob's avatar
    Jacob

    Valentine@32: I was also going to bring up “Cal”, which rather compounds the issue with that clue, but felt I might be piling on!

    Tennessee was indeed TENN, but Kentucky was always KY.

    For those interested in the full and fascinating history of US state postal abbreviations, I recommend https://web.archive.org/web/20120309105923/http://about.usps.com/who-we-are/postal-history/state-abbreviations.pdf

  36. Jacob's avatar
    Jacob

    Valentine@34: That was rather rude. And also incorrect.

    The letter O. was only briefly the accepted abbreviation, up until 1874 (*not* 1969) when it became “Ohio”, which it remained until the 1963 (again, not 1969) standardization, alongside the introduction of ZIP codes. See the official US Postal History I linked to @35.

    If the clue is going to rely on an abbreviation that was obsolete 150 years ago and would be recognized by, I aver, absolutely no living American, it deserves at least an indication that is a “former” abbreviation.

    Furthermore, I didn’t say it wasn’t ever O. I said it has not been O in my 30 years here (and in fact, not even in my lifetime), not even in casual use, which is entirely true. Perhaps you should read the comments more carefully before you post.

  37. Martin's avatar
    Martin

    The amusing story of state name abbreviations.

  38. Mig's avatar
    Mig

    Thank you Brummie for a good start to the week. A confidence booster for one who has struggled lately. Some thought-provoking constructions, but gettable. And consistently superb surfaces, as many have mentioned. All the clues were great, so hard to pick favourites. Maybe single out 20a BIRTHDAY SUIT for the humour (you Brits have an odd sense of duty!) and fine anagram

    Thanks Andrew for an excellent blog

  39. Andrew Sceats's avatar
    Andrew Sceats

    Can anyone tell me what work the question mark is doing in 24ac?

    It’s not ‘definition by example’ because ‘river’ is not an example of OUSE – it’s the other way around.

    What am I missing?

  40. Srivats's avatar
    Srivats

    . Started off as what seemed like an inscrutable rockface! But as I kept at it, the puzzle fielded its runes! Then on at a steady pace. I loved the deep misdirect in WHITE CLIFFS OF DOVER. A cultural reference to an American song that mistreats a British location with love (shades of O for Ohio!) in the past (I was so taken by the poetry, I actually listened to the song) and then aha! An as deep geological one!

  41. bodycheetah's avatar
    bodycheetah

    What’s the problem with CAL / California? I thought it was a fairly common abbreviation e.g. Socal, Caltech etc

  42. Imaginary Cerebellum's avatar
    Imaginary Cerebellum

    Nice to have a puzzle that allows the solver to parse things before writing them in – rather than guessing by the definition and then figuring out some convoluted solution.

    Thanks Brummie. Great balance of solvable clues.

    NHO Antimacassar, but the wordplay was clear enough

    Did I detect a slight American theme? skedaddle, do-si-do, California etc

  43. Crispy's avatar
    Crispy

    Valentine @32 – “Though I don’t think Utah, our other four-letter state, suffered the same fate.”. Is Iowa no longer a state then?

  44. m's avatar
    m

    #41 Cal as a shortening of California is reasonable and you make a good point re socal/caltech. Caltrain, calpoly are other examples. O as a standin for Ohio is NOT at least in my book. Don’t care if Chamber’s has it or not. Cal only adds to CA whereas O down from OH makes it more ambiguous.

  45. bodycheetah's avatar
    bodycheetah

    AS@39 perhaps the question mark is a DBE indicator for privy?

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.