Guardian 24,854 / Brendan
Posted by Andrew on November 11th, 2009
A tour-de-force of linked clues and clever wordplay from Brendan that is exceptional even by his high standards. Unfortunately I’ve had to solve and blog this in rather a hurry before catching an early train (so also won’t be able to reply to comments until the evening): there’s lots here to savour.
Key:
dd = double definition
* = anagram
< = reverse
| Across | ||||||||
| 1. | BOMBAY | MOB< "before the horse", the horse being a BAY | ||||||
| 4. | INTERCOM | CO in IN TERM | ||||||
| 9,22. | CHANGE ENDS | dd – the courts are for tennis, not law | ||||||
| 10. | WAGGONER | GO (=pass) in WAGNER | ||||||
| 11,21. | PUTTING THE CART BEFORE THE HORSE | PUTTING (=presenting) + CHATTER* + BEFORE (=in front of) + (OTHERS HE)*. Just so this blog isn’t unqualified praise, I think it’s a small blemish that PUTTING has more or less the same meaning in both wordplay and answer. | ||||||
| 13. | THE FORTIES | OR in THEFT, IE S | ||||||
| 14. | YARD | The clue expands to “Measure putting cart back to front”, so it’s DRAY<. Brilliant combination of two of the long answers. | ||||||
| 16. | NOTE | ETON. The definition is “mark”, as in “mark my words” | ||||||
| 18. | OUT OF ORDER | dd | ||||||
| 23. | ACOUSTIC | (a)CCUSATIO(n)* – another amazing clue | ||||||
| 24. | SOLEMN | SOLE M(a)N | ||||||
| 25. | RETRORSE | (ERROR SET)* More clever cross-referencing. A biological word meaning “turned back or downward” | ||||||
| 26. | RECTOS | SECTOR with a “change of ends” | ||||||
| Down | ||||||||
| 1,17. | BACK TO FRONT | War “like this”, i.e. back to front, is “raw”, i.e. “painful”. | ||||||
| 2. | MEASURE | ME + A SURE | ||||||
| 3. | ANGSTROM | ANGST + ROM (= romany). An angstrom is a tenth of a nanometer. | ||||||
| 5. | NEAR THE BONE | N EARTH + EBON + (hol)E. “Almost blue” is a nice definition. | ||||||
| 6. | EAGLET | LEGATE* | ||||||
| 7. | CANTATA | CAN (”one way to preserve”) + TATA (goodbye). | ||||||
| 8. | MARY TUDOR | D in MORTUARY* | ||||||
| 12. | NET CURTAINS | NET = final (as in net profit etc) + CURTAINS (”it’s curtains for you, Bugsy”). | ||||||
| 13. | TONY BLAIR | (I NOTABLY (majo)R)* &lit. The brilliance keeps on coming. | ||||||
| 15. | MONOTONE | MO (= moment = second) + NOT ONE | ||||||
| 19. | DESSERT | TRESSED< | ||||||
| 20. | PRESTO | P + REST + O. It means “quickly” in a musical score. | ||||||
November 11th, 2009 at 8:11 am
Very many thanks, Andrew, this was a truly wonderful puzzle. The best of the week? Brendan was very tricky but that’s how I like them.
25a RETRORSE was a new word for me but it was guessable.
Also, many thanks Brendan. You are a tsar. Or should that be star?
November 11th, 2009 at 8:54 am
Many thanks, Andrew – you must have been up very early!
As you say, this was an excellent puzzle. I was, initially, rather disappointed at getting 11,21 immediately, from the enumeration, without having to think about it, but soon realised that there was much more to it than that. I should have known better, since it’s Brendan!
There were some very ingenious clues [e.g. 23ac and 15dn] and great surfaces [e.g. 4ac,9,22, 8dn and, best of all, 13dn].
Many thanks, Brendan, for a great start to the day!
November 11th, 2009 at 9:49 am
Just brilliant.
November 11th, 2009 at 10:20 am
This is unquestionably a contender for one of the best Guardian Cryptics of 2009.
It had everything. Ingenuity, wit, stunning reversals.
Thanks for the blog Andrew and Bravo Brendan!
November 11th, 2009 at 10:48 am
I could only manage about half of it, but having seen the final solution I can certainly see what Ian is saying – extremely clever and witty puzzle.
November 11th, 2009 at 11:52 am
Thanks, Andrew. The praise is entirely justified — this was a real tour de force! Like Eileen, I saw 11, 21 almost immediately and got about halfway through quite quickly. After that, I found it much harder-going, but always enjoyable.
RETRORSE was new to me.
I didn’t see all of the wordplay, so reading the blog only made me appreciate this puzzle more.
November 11th, 2009 at 12:58 pm
I can only echo those sentiments. Public holiday here in France so a chance to get down to it reasonably early. Like Eileen I thought at first it was going to be easy but several twists at the end (and I’m still kicking myself over SOLEMN, having told myself that an MN ending wouldn’t go – our classicist Ralph would not be impressed). Well done Brendan.
November 11th, 2009 at 1:01 pm
I have to agree – an excellent puzzle. The only (slight) disappointment, as others have said, was getting 11,21 straight away from the definition and enumeration, and only fathoming the wordplay afterwards.
Thanks, Andrew. I didn’t get the wordplay for MONOTONE myself, but see it now.
November 11th, 2009 at 1:17 pm
The answer to 20dn provides a possible new nickname for Freddie Flintoff, who comes from Preston.
November 11th, 2009 at 1:38 pm
A fine piece of work, but (re 3 down) is ROM a recognised abbreviation for Romany?
November 11th, 2009 at 2:21 pm
BarryW – no, ROM is a word in its own right, from the Romany for man.
November 11th, 2009 at 6:10 pm
Thanks for the blog Andrew.
Brendan never fails to please.
13dn TONY BLAIR: brilliant!
November 11th, 2009 at 8:11 pm
Yes, another great Brendan. I only managed one answer on the way in (5 mins it took), as I stupidly forgot my pen and tried to do it in my head. On the way back, I also got 11a etc quite quickly, but, I wonder, if I hadn’t, how difficult it would have been. 53 minutes altogether, with 16 mins on the last 4 (26a, 25a, 20d [had PRONTO for a while] and then 23a).
November 11th, 2009 at 9:14 pm
Agree with everyone above.
A nearly perfect crossword, not even that time consuming.
(nearly, because I think, 6d is too simple (unworthy of this excellent Brendan),
but then – you have to make a start sómewhere)
So, why this post, when I have nothing to add?
(a) Just to show my admiration for Brendan
(b) To say some words to Kathryn’s Dad (after yesterday’s Rufus discussion): “that’s just great, and the right way to tackle crosswords (try the best you can, and then “read” the solutions)”
November 11th, 2009 at 9:55 pm
Another class specimen. Went well with ale I thought. Will Thurs, Fri, Sat live up to these?
November 11th, 2009 at 10:42 pm
Poor old Kathryn’s Dad! Poor old beginners everywhere, for that matter. Because without some sort of mentor it’s quite likely to be a losing battle with the likes of Brendan. I mean, you’ve hardly learned your vowels and along comes Finnegans Wake.
Back in the day I had no such bother, with mighty Araucaria buff Jed, founder and lead (well, to be honest, only) trombonist of proto-legendary New Forest jazz-rockers Egg on Legs, to assist me. And Ringwood’s Old Thumper, of course.
Another excellent puzzle from a really gifted thinker.
November 12th, 2009 at 12:21 am
I think these last two puzzles have been great. Both contained clues that allow the solver to feel clever when they crack them.
November 12th, 2009 at 9:12 am
Strangely as a beginner, I thought this one wasn’t too bad. A nice big easy clue to start with is always good. I didn’t quite finish it, but spent a long time enjoying the struggle.
November 12th, 2009 at 3:35 pm
I got stuck on 24 across which could easily have been SOMBRE as in S + (H)OMBRE (Heartless guy). I was so sure!
November 12th, 2009 at 6:03 pm
Bloody fantastic stuff!
I have been at a rather boring conference in Cardiff for the past two days and this, plus today’s Punk, helped relieve the tedium.
November 12th, 2009 at 11:12 pm
I’ve just done this one on the train on the way home from work tonight (Thursday). So glad I saved it rather than chucking the paper out as I would normally have done. I can only repeat everyone else’s admiration – totally and utterly brilliant.
13d has to be Clue Of The Year, surely? Hilarious!
November 14th, 2009 at 2:16 pm
Andrew: thanks for mentioning that this was such a good puzzle in your comment yesterday – I didn’t have time to do it on the day, and probably wouldn’t have gone back otherwise.
I absolutely agree with the above comments: a really excellent puzzle, at a quite reasonable difficulty level for a weekday…